Charitable Blog

Everything you need to know about Charitable and our team.

Add Donors to your MailerLite and Mailster Email Marketing Lists

Last updated on

  • By

Version 1.2.0 of Newsletter Connect comes out today and adds support for two new email marketing providers: MailerLite and Mailster.

Never heard of them?

I’ll make a confession: neither had I! But after working on this release I have been very impressed with both products. Read on to learn what makes these two email marketing products shine.

MailerLite: Simple, Affordable with All the Features You Need

MailerLite markets itself as an affordable alternative to market leaders like MailChimp, Campaign Monitor and ConvertKit. And if price is a key concern for you, MailerLite could be an excellent choice for you: their Forever Free plan includes all their features (including automation & 24/7 email support) and doesn’t require an upgrade until you hit 1000 subscribers. Once you hit that threshold it’s still pretty affordable — check their pricing to see what your monthly bill would be.

No matter which plan you are on, you have access to the full set of MailerLite features. That includes a drag and drop editor for creating emails, access to pre-designed email templates, subscriber management, popup and landing page makers, and automation. The app dashboard is clean, simple and intuitive.

Our integration with MailerLite allows you to easily start adding donors to your lists (called groups in MailerLite). As with all our newsletter integrations, you can subscribe donors to different lists depending on the campaign they donate to and you can choose whether to show an opt-in or opt-out in the donation form, or subscribe donors automatically without any opt-in.

Mailster: Powerful Newsletter Plugin for WordPress

I hadn’t heard of Mailster, but I knew it by its previous name: MyMail. The renamed and revamped product is a beautiful, rock solid newsletter plugin for WordPress.

Mailster allows you to create campaigns, manage subscribers and set up powerful auto responders, right there in your WordPress dashboard. Everything is intuitive and easy to use.

Unlike MailerLite and other subscription-based email marketing services, Mailster has no recurring fees. You buy it once for $49 and then have access to lifetime plugin updates and the ability to send as many emails as you want, forever. You can also purchase additional premium templates for your email campaigns.

Since Mailster lives in your WordPress dashboard, it’s very easy to use it alongside Charitable. With Mailster and Newsletter Connect activated on your site, you can start adding donors to your Mailster lists. You could even create separate lists for different campaigns, with unique autoresponders for each — it’s a powerful combination.

Looking for a different email marketing provider?

Do you use an email marketing service we don’t support? Let us know!

We added support for Mailster and MailerLite after customers asked for it, and we would love to continue to expand the collection of email marketing services you can use for your non-profit’s email marketing and newsletters.


If you are already using Charitable Newsletter Connect and you have activated your license, you can update to version 1.2.0 via your WordPress dashboard. You can also download it from your account area.

Not sure if Newsletter Connect is for you? Find out why email marketing is an essential tool for every modern non-profit.

author avatar
Eric Daams

Disclosure: Our content is reader-supported. This means if you click on some of our links, then we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that we believe will add value to our readers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get free tips and resources right in your inbox, along with 60,000+ others

Join our Newsletter

We won’t spam you. We only send an email when we think it will genuinely help you. Unsubscribe at any time!

Featured Video:

Watch more videos on our YouTube channel.

What's New In Charitable

🔔 Subscribe to get our latest updates
📧 Subscribe to Emails

Email Subscription

Join our Newsletter

We won’t spam you. We only send an email when we think it will genuinely help you. Unsubscribe at any time!

Integration New

WordPress Command Palette Integration

Take your fundraising workflow to the next level. Speed up your site management and stay in your creative flow with our new WordPress Command Palette integration.

Supercharge Your Workflow
Navigate your fundraising dashboard faster than ever.

The Ultimate Keyboard Shortcut Hit Cmd + K (or Ctrl + K) to launch the Command Palette and manage your campaigns instantly.

⚡ Instant Navigation: Jump directly to your Campaigns, Donations, or Settings from anywhere in the editor.

➕ Quick Create: Start a new fundraising campaign or add a manual donation with a single command.

Efficiency Redefined
The tools you need, exactly when you need them.

⚙️ Contextual Actions: See relevant Charitable commands based on whether you’re editing a page or viewing your reports.

🚀 Seamless Integration: Built directly into the WordPress core experience for a lightweight, native feel.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Improvement New Security

📣 New Security Features

We’ve introduced a suite of new security tools to give you total control over who accesses your forms, plus a new way to tidy up your database.

Advanced Security Suite

Layered protection: Cloudflare, ReCAPTCHA, IP Controls, and Rate Limiting.

We have overhauled our security settings to stop bots without blocking real donors.

  • 🤖 Flexible Protection: Choose between Google reCAPTCHA v3 or the privacy-first Cloudflare Turnstile to block bots invisible.

  • 🚦 Rate limiting: Stop spam floods by limiting how many submissions an IP address can make in a set timeframe.

  • 🛑 Total control: Use the new IP Blacklist to block bad actors instantly, or the IP Whitelist to let your team bypass checks during testing.

The Clean Donation Tool

Go from “Testing” to “Live” in seconds.

Finished setting up your site and need to get rid of all those test transactions?

  • 🧹 Sweep it clean: Bulk delete test donations and donor records with a single click.

  • 📉 Accurate reporting: Ensure your revenue stats are 100% accurate for launch day.

  • ⚙️ Reset sequences: Automatically resets sequential invoice numbering.

author avatar
Eric Daams
donation form New

🏗️ Visual Donation Form Builder

Building the perfect donation form just got easier. We have completely reimagined how you create forms with a new drag-and-drop interface.

Design Visually, in Real-Time

No coding, no guessing. Just point, click, and build.

Say goodbye to confusing settings pages. You can now edit your form and see exactly what your donors will see, instantly.

  • 🖱️ Drag & Drop: Easily add fields like names, addresses, or file uploads by dragging them exactly where you want them.

  • 🎨 Customize everything: Click any field to tweak labels, placeholders, and requirement settings on the fly.

  • 👁️ Live preview: See your changes immediately as you make them—ensure your form flows perfectly before you hit publish.

Flexible & Powerful

Works with all your existing campaigns.

  • 🧩 Deep customization: Add custom HTML, shortcodes, or CSS classes for advanced branding.

  • ⚙️ Smart fields: Collect exactly what you need with support for dropdowns, checkboxes, dates, and hidden fields.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Leaderboards New

🏆 Donor Leaderboards!

Turn your fundraising into a community event. Recognize your most generous supporters and inspire friendly competition with our new leaderboard tools.

Gamify Your Fundraising

Celebrate your top donors and encourage others to climb the ranks.

Create a public “Hall of Fame” to give your donors the recognition they deserve.

  • 🎨 Two stunning layouts: Choose the List View for a clean, data-rich table or the Card View for a modern, visual grid with avatars.

  • 🥇 Automatic highlights: The top 3 supporters get special Trophy and Crown icons to make them stand out.

  • 🧩 Place it anywhere: Add it to any page using the new Gutenberg Block, or drop it directly into your campaign using the Visual Builder.

Total Customization

You decide what to show and what to hide.

  • ⚙️ Flexible data: Choose to display or hide donation amounts, donor counts, or avatars.

  • 🔄 Lifetime stats: Works seamlessly with Recurring Donations to show a donor’s all-time total impact.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Improvement New templates

🎨 New Templates & List Builder

Launch faster and design better. We’ve added three professional campaign templates and a versatile new content block to help you tell your story.

3 New Campaign Templates

Ready-to-use designs for specific fundraising needs.

Don’t start from scratch. Pick a template tailored to your cause and launch in minutes.

  • 🎄 Holiday Fundraiser: A warm, festive design perfect for year-end giving, toy drives, or food pantries.

  • 🎓 School Fundraiser: Built for PTAs and sports teams. clearly highlights goals like playground upgrades or classroom tech.

  • Church Fundraiser: A trustworthy layout designed for building funds, mission trips, and tithes.

The New “List” Block

Organize your campaign details without writing code.

Make your campaign pages easier to scan and more visually engaging with our new builder block.

  • 📝 Flexible layouts: Choose from 3 distinct styles to display sponsorship levels, donation perks, or project goals.

  • 🎨 Rich customization: Add colorful headlines, support for emojis, and unlimited list items.

  • 👣 Smart footers: Include a built-in footer for extra context or a final Call to Action.

author avatar
Eric Daams