Charitable Blog

Everything you need to know about Charitable and our team.

Add Donors to your MailerLite and Mailster Email Marketing Lists

Last updated on

  • By

Version 1.2.0 of Newsletter Connect comes out today and adds support for two new email marketing providers: MailerLite and Mailster.

Never heard of them?

I’ll make a confession: neither had I! But after working on this release I have been very impressed with both products. Read on to learn what makes these two email marketing products shine.

MailerLite: Simple, Affordable with All the Features You Need

MailerLite markets itself as an affordable alternative to market leaders like MailChimp, Campaign Monitor and ConvertKit. And if price is a key concern for you, MailerLite could be an excellent choice for you: their Forever Free plan includes all their features (including automation & 24/7 email support) and doesn’t require an upgrade until you hit 1000 subscribers. Once you hit that threshold it’s still pretty affordable — check their pricing to see what your monthly bill would be.

No matter which plan you are on, you have access to the full set of MailerLite features. That includes a drag and drop editor for creating emails, access to pre-designed email templates, subscriber management, popup and landing page makers, and automation. The app dashboard is clean, simple and intuitive.

Our integration with MailerLite allows you to easily start adding donors to your lists (called groups in MailerLite). As with all our newsletter integrations, you can subscribe donors to different lists depending on the campaign they donate to and you can choose whether to show an opt-in or opt-out in the donation form, or subscribe donors automatically without any opt-in.

Mailster: Powerful Newsletter Plugin for WordPress

I hadn’t heard of Mailster, but I knew it by its previous name: MyMail. The renamed and revamped product is a beautiful, rock solid newsletter plugin for WordPress.

Mailster allows you to create campaigns, manage subscribers and set up powerful auto responders, right there in your WordPress dashboard. Everything is intuitive and easy to use.

Unlike MailerLite and other subscription-based email marketing services, Mailster has no recurring fees. You buy it once for $49 and then have access to lifetime plugin updates and the ability to send as many emails as you want, forever. You can also purchase additional premium templates for your email campaigns.

Since Mailster lives in your WordPress dashboard, it’s very easy to use it alongside Charitable. With Mailster and Newsletter Connect activated on your site, you can start adding donors to your Mailster lists. You could even create separate lists for different campaigns, with unique autoresponders for each — it’s a powerful combination.

Looking for a different email marketing provider?

Do you use an email marketing service we don’t support? Let us know!

We added support for Mailster and MailerLite after customers asked for it, and we would love to continue to expand the collection of email marketing services you can use for your non-profit’s email marketing and newsletters.


If you are already using Charitable Newsletter Connect and you have activated your license, you can update to version 1.2.0 via your WordPress dashboard. You can also download it from your account area.

Not sure if Newsletter Connect is for you? Find out why email marketing is an essential tool for every modern non-profit.

author avatar
Eric Daams

Disclosure: Our content is reader-supported. This means if you click on some of our links, then we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that we believe will add value to our readers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get free tips and resources right in your inbox, along with 60,000+ others

Join our Newsletter

We won’t spam you. We only send an email when we think it will genuinely help you. Unsubscribe at any time!

Featured Video:

Watch more videos on our YouTube channel.

What's New In Charitable

View The Latest Updates
🔔 Subscribe to get our latest updates
📧 Subscribe to Emails

Email Subscription

Join our Newsletter

We won’t spam you. We only send an email when we think it will genuinely help you. Unsubscribe at any time!

Campaigns New

🧡 Modal Donate Button: Turn Any Click into a Contribution

Instead of redirecting users to a new URL, the lightweight Modal Donation Button allows donors to complete their gift in a sleek, focused popup, keeping them engaged with your content while they support your cause.

What’s New:

  • Zero-Friction Giving: Open your donation form in a responsive modal overlay. Donors stay on the same page, reducing drop-off.

  • 🖱️ Place it Anywhere: Use the dedicated WordPress block or a simple shortcode to drop a donate button into sidebars, footers, or even mid-sentence in your storytelling.

  • 🎨 Full Design Control: Match your brand perfectly with customizable background colors, hover effects, border radius, and font sizes—all without touching a single line of CSS.

Whether you need a simple “Donate Now” link or a high-converting popup button, the Modal Donate Button gives you the flexibility to raise more with less effort.

author avatar
Eric Daams
donation form Donations New

💵 Mini Donation Widget: Show The Impact Of Every Dollar!

Not every donor who wants to give will navigate to your campaign page. Meet them exactly where they are by placing a fully functional giving experience directly on any page or post.

💬 Show the impact of every dollar: Attach custom messages to each preset amount so donors understand exactly what their gift provides.
🔄 Monthly and one-time giving: Supports a tabbed interface with independent amounts and impact statements for recurring giving programs.
🎨 Match your brand: Easily set accent colors and control size or alignment to fit the widget naturally into your layout without CSS.
⚡ Reduce donor friction: Open the donation form in a modal overlay to keep donors on the page and reduce drop-off.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Donations Live New

👉🏻 Showcase Real Momentum with the Donations Feed

Give your donors a reason to trust. Our new feed lets you display a living, breathing record of people showing up for your cause.

🤝 Build instant trust: Overcome donor hesitation by showing a proven track record of community support.
💬 Highlight donor stories: Display real donor comments and locations to show the human side of your fundraising.
🛠️ Drop it anywhere: Easily add the block to your homepage, campaign pages, or confirmation screens in seconds.
📈 Curate your feed: Group multiple donations from the same person or sort by highest amounts to encourage larger gifts.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Campaigns New

🎨 Campaign Showcase: Pro Level Display, No Coding Needed.

Display your causes with style and make it easier than ever for donors to find the right campaign. We are excited to announce the brand-new Campaign Showcase, a powerful, no-code tool designed to help you create beautiful, high-converting campaign grids and carousels.

The Ultimate Discovery Experience

Your mission deserves to be seen. With the Campaign Showcase, you can move beyond simple lists and create dynamic displays that highlight your most urgent needs, helping donors connect with the causes they care about most.

⚡ No-Code Customization: Effortlessly change layouts, columns, and styles with a single click. Whether you want a clean grid or an interactive carousel, you can match your organization’s look without any CSS or JavaScript.

🎯 Advanced Search & Filter: Empower your supporters with real-time filtering. Donors can quickly sort through campaigns by tags, popularity, or “ending soon,” making it easy to find exactly where their help is needed.

💰 Quick Donate Integration: Boost your conversions with instant giving. The Showcase allows donors to contribute via a modal popup directly from the display, featuring pre-selected amounts for a faster, friction-free experience.

author avatar
Eric Daams
Addon New

🤯 New Addon: Campaign Updates

Keep your supporters informed and engaged with every step of your progress! Share the ongoing impact of your mission and build lasting trust with your donor community!

The Ultimate Engagement Tool

Fundraising is a journey, not a one-time event. Now, you can easily provide real-time updates directly on your campaign pages, ensuring your donors stay connected to the causes they care about most.

📣 Easy Storytelling: Quickly post text updates, milestones, or field reports to show exactly how donations are being put to work, keeping the momentum alive throughout your fundraiser.

🏗️ Visual Builder Integration: Seamlessly add the Updates block anywhere on your page using our drag-and-drop builder, or use a simple shortcode to display news in widgets and sidebars.

📩 Build Donor Trust: By consistently sharing progress and success stories, you create a transparent giving experience that encourages recurring support and deeper community involvement.

author avatar
Eric Daams